Finally: Carly Smithson is Voted Off 'American Idol.'

She's the one with a background of music labels and failure on those labels. AI's producers didn't seem to mind but America DID! The songs of Andrew Lloyd Webber weren't the only theatrics on "American Idol" this week, as tattooed finalist Carly Smithson was booted from the show last night (April 24).

Despite a soulful performance of Lloyd Webber's "Jesus Christ Superstar," the 24-year-old San Diego native was corralled with the other bottom third, Syesha Mercado, before host Ryan Seacrest delivered the bad news.